Hybrid Toilet Systems

A hybrid toilet system separates three kinds of wastes:  urine, solids, and blackwater/greywater. It combines a urine-diverting (UD) toilet, a separator and composting system for the solids, and a blackwater/greywater drain.

An eco-toilet is any toilet that uses less water and recovers more nutrients than a conventional flush toilet. Ideally, it should do both – use no water and recover all nutrients.

Starting June 2014, we have have been using and testing a new eco-toilet design that meets these high standards. It combines a waterless, urine-diverting toilet from Sweden, and a modular-bin composting system from Vermont. The result is an eco-toilet that  is pleasant for the user, waterless, urine-diverting, energy efficient, meets high sanitation standards, is easy to use and maintain, and recovers virtually all the nutrients.

This hybrid design is being monitored by the Barnstable County Department of Health and Environment as part of Falmouth’s Eco-Toilet Demonstration Program to determine the degree to which the system reduces the amount of nutrients in wastewater.

Please read below, or download the Hybrid Eco-Toilet Report. You can also read about other commercially-available hybrid systems.


Nutrient storage & recovery

The urine storage tank can be either in the basement or outside in the ground near the house.

It should be large enough to hold at least six months of urine, so a two-person household should have a tank that is at least 150 gallons in size. The capacity actually needed is affected by the number of people in the household and the lifestyle of the household (ranging from rarely home to entertaining lots of guests). The total capacity can include more than one tank. We recommend an on-site capacity to hold a year’s volume to reduce the number of pump-outs required.

The urine can be removed from the tank by either filling five-gallon sealable buckets or jugs with tight lids via a spigot located near
the bottom of the storage tank for removal. An electronic system can be installed that warns the homeowner and/or the service company that the tank is nearly full and service is needed in a few weeks.

The compost starts as a layered mixture of feces, toilet paper, wood shavings and optionally facial tissues and paper towels in the blue bin. When used by two people, it takes about 6-12 months for the bin to fill up.

Fig. 1: Removal of a full bin from the chute

Fig. 1: Removal of a full bin from the chute

To see if bin is full, the homeowner can either open the lid and look, or install an optional electronic warning sensor. When a bin becomes full it is disconnected from the chute, (Fig.1) and a new empty bin is put in its place, (Fig. 2).

Once it’s filled, the bin is set aside for secondary composting. After topping it off with some garden soil, a layer of wood shavings and some water, a new lid is put on and connected to continuous aeration, using the same fan system that provides ventilation for the active bin, allowing it to compost more completely for a longer retention time. During that time pathogens are gradually eliminated in the process.

Fig. 2: Installation of a new empty bin to the chute

Fig. 2: Installation of a new empty bin to the chute

The volume and weight of the finished compost will be much less than the starting material, due to more complete decomposition and evaporation of moisture. The volume of compost in the bin, after a one-year retention time, is reduced by 50-80%. The volume of finished compost produced by one person in one year is about 18 gallons. Further retention time will reduce the volume more.

The finished compost material removed from the bin is slightly moist and looks like rich garden compost. The bin can be wheeled outdoors to be emptied. The empty bin is stored for later use.

Please read about home-scale nutrient recycling for more information about the next steps.

For more information, please visit the following pages:

Why Recycle Nutrients?

Large Bin Composting Systems

Large Batch Composting Systems

Self-Contained Waterless Systems

Urine-Diverting Systems

6 responses to “Hybrid Toilet Systems

  1. that is so cool!!! poop is the best fertilizer ever!!! Ive always used it on my tomato and marijuana plants. It seriously grows the best weed you can imagine!!! ❤

  2. I am convinced and ready!
    Where can I get the components for this system? I live on an island in Maine and will not qualify for the Massachusetts incentives. I already have a Separett (have not installed it yet) but the bins you are using here are much better than anything I have found up here.
    Thank you so much for your hard work in developing this idea!
    Warm Regards,

    • Thanks for your interest in the hybrid eco-toilet.
      Hi Iana! You can find out more information about the Full Circle composting toilet system at fullcirclecompost.org Abe Noe-Hays invented the composting bin system and he built the one we are using and testing.

  3. Pingback: We made it to Separett’s newsletter! | Cape Cod Eco-Toilet Center·

  4. Hello, My name is Andrew Nagy. I am an ambitious 14-year-old entrepreneur and I had an idea similar to this. So, my idea consists of a generic toilet with three buttons. One button to flush, one button to select solid waste, and another to select liquid waste such as urine or graywater. If you choose liquid waste, the water inside of the toilet will disperse into sockets inside of the base of the toilet. This way, we do not waste water on flushing urine or graywater. This will prevent yellow rings in the toilets and I estimated that it will save hundreds of gallons in a year, depending on the average rate of flushes of urine, the specific toilet, and of course, the amount of liters per flush. Solid waste will be disposed of the traditional way, and this idea is focusing on liquid wastes. If anything were to get stuck in the toilet on the liquid waste setting, you can just flush the toilet normally without any complications. If you think my idea has a place in the real world, I would love your feedback.

    • Thanks for your comment and idea, Andrew! Do you have any drawings of your concept? What would happen to the liquid waste in the sockets at the base of the toilet?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s